23 Pizza Toppings That Deserve A Place Among The All Time Greats

Photo of author

By Oliver Drayton

Pizza is one of the most loved foods on the planet, and the toppings are what make each slice special. Some toppings have been around for centuries, while others are newer favorites that won people over fast.

Picking the right ones can turn a plain pie into something you will remember for weeks. Here are the toppings that have truly earned their spot on the pizza hall of fame.

1. Pepperoni, The Undisputed Champion

Pepperoni, The Undisputed Champion
© QSR Magazine

Walk into almost any pizza shop in America and pepperoni will be the top seller. Surveys show that more than a third of pizza orders include it, which makes it the king of toppings.

Those little slices curl into crispy cups when they bake, holding tiny pools of tasty, spicy oil. For the best crunch, look for thinner, natural-casing pepperoni.

Add it right on top of the cheese so the edges can crisp up nicely.

2. Fresh Mozzarella

Fresh Mozzarella
© Brian Lagerstrom

Soft, milky, and a little bit stretchy, fresh mozzarella is the heart of a classic Neapolitan pizza. It tastes clean and creamy instead of salty.

Here is a handy trick. Fresh mozzarella holds a lot of water, so tear it into pieces and pat it dry with a paper towel before baking.

That way your crust stays crisp instead of soggy.

Pair it with tomato and basil, and you have a timeless winner.

3. Italian Sausage

Italian Sausage
© JoyFoodSunshine

Grandma’s Sunday sauce often had sausage in it, and pizza makers borrowed the idea for good reason. Crumbled Italian sausage brings juicy, savory bites seasoned with fennel and garlic.

The fennel seeds give it a slightly sweet, almost licorice flavor that makes it special. Choose mild or hot depending on your spice comfort level.

Always brown raw sausage a little before topping your pie, so it cooks all the way through.

4. Mushrooms

Mushrooms
© Food with Feeling

Earthy and meaty without any meat at all, mushrooms are a vegetarian’s best friend on pizza. They soak up garlic, butter, and herbs like little sponges.

Did you know mushrooms are mostly water? Sauteing them for a few minutes first removes moisture and deepens their flavor.

Try mixing types, like cremini, shiitake, and oyster mushrooms, for a woodsy pie that tastes fancy but is easy to make at home.

5. Fresh Basil

Fresh Basil
© Our Zesty Life

Legend says the Margherita pizza was made in 1889 to honor Queen Margherita of Italy. Its red tomato, white cheese, and green basil matched the Italian flag.

Basil adds a sweet, peppery smell that makes every bite feel fresh. The key is timing.

Add the leaves right after the pizza comes out of the oven so they stay bright green instead of turning dark and crispy.

6. Caramelized Onions

Caramelized Onions
© The Picky Eater

Patience pays off big time with this one. Cooking onions low and slow for about 40 minutes turns them sweet, jammy, and golden brown.

Raw onions can be sharp, but caramelized ones taste almost like candy. They pair beautifully with salty cheeses like goat cheese or blue cheese.

Make a big batch on the weekend and keep it in the fridge. You will have a gourmet topping ready whenever pizza night rolls around.

7. Bacon

Bacon
© Taste of Home

Is there anything bacon cannot improve? Smoky, salty, and crunchy, it brings breakfast vibes to any pizza.

Many people make the mistake of putting raw bacon on pizza, which leaves it chewy and greasy. Cook it about halfway first, then chop it into bits and scatter it on top.

It shines alongside ranch, barbecue chicken, or even pineapple. Fair warning, once you try it, plain cheese may feel a little lonely.

8. Pineapple

Pineapple
© Bowl of Delicious

Few toppings start arguments like pineapple. Funny enough, Hawaiian pizza was invented in Canada in 1962 by a Greek immigrant named Sam Panopoulos.

Love it or not, the sweet and tangy fruit balances salty meats like ham and bacon perfectly. The heat of the oven even caramelizes the edges a bit.

Fans who want an extra kick can add jalapenos. That sweet and spicy combo might just win over the doubters.

9. Green Bell Peppers

Green Bell Peppers
© Nordic Ware

Crunch matters, and green bell peppers deliver it. Their slightly bitter, grassy flavor cuts through rich cheese and fatty meats.

You will find them on nearly every supreme pizza, and for good reason. They add color, vitamin C, and a fresh snap.

Slice them thin so they soften in the oven but still keep a little bite. Red and yellow peppers work too if you prefer something sweeter.

10. Black Olives

Black Olives
© Splash of Taste

Kids everywhere have stuck black olives on their fingertips at least once. On pizza, though, these little rings earn real respect.

They bring a mild, buttery saltiness that blends easily with other toppings. Because canned black olives are already cooked, they are simple to use straight from the can.

Just drain them well first. Want more punch?

Swap in Kalamata olives for a bolder, Mediterranean twist on your slice.

11. Spicy Soppressata

Spicy Soppressata
© Serious Eats

Think of soppressata as pepperoni’s cooler Italian cousin. This dry-cured salami is coarser, spicier, and packed with peppery flavor.

Trendy pizza shops love pairing it with a drizzle of hot honey. The sweet honey and spicy meat create a flavor fireworks show in your mouth.

Look for it at the deli counter, sliced thin. A little goes a long way, so a few pieces per slice is plenty.

12. Ham

Ham
© Barefoot In The Pines

Mild, smoky, and friendly to just about everyone, ham is the easygoing topping that plays well with others. Picky eaters usually say yes to it.

Diced ham spreads evenly and stays tender in the oven. For something more grown-up, try thin slices of prosciutto, an Italian cured ham.

One tip about prosciutto, though. Add it after baking so it stays silky and does not turn tough and salty.

13. Jalapenos

Jalapenos
© Erica’s Recipes

Heat seekers, this one is for you. Jalapenos bring a bright, zingy kick that wakes up every bite.

Fresh slices give a crisp, grassy heat, while pickled ones add tang along with the spice. Both are tasty, so pick based on your mood.

To tame the fire, scrape out the seeds and white ribs before slicing. Cool them down further by pairing with pineapple or a ranch dipping sauce.

14. Roasted Garlic

Roasted Garlic
© The Paleo Running Momma

Raw garlic can bite back, but roasted garlic is a whole different story. After baking whole bulbs in foil for about 45 minutes, the cloves turn soft, sweet, and spreadable.

Smear them right onto the dough or scatter whole cloves across the top. They taste incredible on white pizzas with ricotta.

Bonus fact: garlic lovers in Gilroy, California hold a festival every year celebrating the stinky, wonderful bulb.

15. Spinach

Spinach
© The Foul-Mouth Gourmet

Sneaking greens into dinner has never been easier. Spinach shrinks down in the oven and melts right into the cheese.

Fresh baby spinach works well, but squeeze frozen spinach dry if you use it. Extra water is the enemy of crispy crust.

For a Greek-style pie, team it with feta, garlic, and olives. It is a smart way to make pizza feel a bit lighter without losing any fun.

16. Barbecue Chicken

Barbecue Chicken
© Feel Good Foodie

Back in 1985, California Pizza Kitchen helped make barbecue chicken pizza famous, and it quickly became a modern classic.

Swapping tomato sauce for tangy barbecue sauce changes everything. Add shredded chicken, thin red onion, and smoked gouda, then finish with fresh cilantro.

Leftover rotisserie chicken is perfect here and saves time. It tastes like a backyard cookout, only you get to eat it with your hands on the couch.

17. Anchovies

Anchovies
© Mob

Anchovies get teased a lot in movies, but chefs secretly adore them. These tiny salted fish pack a huge burst of savory flavor.

Here is the surprising part. When anchovies bake, they melt and lose their fishy taste, leaving behind a deep, salty richness.

Start small with just a few fillets chopped up. Italian pizzerias have used them for generations on pies like Napoletana with capers and oregano.

18. Ricotta Cheese

Ricotta Cheese
© The clever meal

Picture little clouds of creamy cheese dotting your pizza. Ricotta adds a soft, gentle richness that feels fancy yet comforting.

It does not melt like mozzarella. Instead, it stays in fluffy dollops that cool down spicy toppings.

Mix it with a pinch of salt, lemon zest, and black pepper before spooning it on. Try it with sausage or mushrooms, and you will wonder why you waited so long.

19. Sun-Dried Tomatoes

Sun-Dried Tomatoes
© The clever meal

Concentrated is the best word for sun-dried tomatoes. Drying removes the water, leaving a chewy, sweet, and tangy bite that tastes like summer.

Oil-packed versions are softer and ready to use, while dry ones should soak in warm water for a few minutes.

They brighten up white pizzas and pair nicely with chicken, artichokes, or goat cheese. Save the flavorful jar oil for brushing on your crust.

20. Arugula

Arugula
© Olivia’s Cuisine

Fresh greens on hot pizza might sound odd, but arugula proves the idea brilliant. Its peppery leaves add a crisp, cool contrast.

Toss a handful with olive oil and lemon juice, then pile it on right after baking. Top with shaved parmesan or prosciutto for a restaurant-style finish.

Every bite becomes warm and fresh at once. It is like pizza and salad decided to become best friends.

21. Artichoke Hearts

Artichoke Hearts
© Kathryns Kitchen Blog

Spinach artichoke dip fans, rejoice. Those tender, tangy artichoke hearts taste just as amazing on pizza.

Marinated artichokes from a jar are the easiest choice and already full of herby flavor. Chop them into quarters and drain off extra oil.

Fun fact: almost all artichokes grown in the United States come from California. Pair them with spinach and garlic for a slice that feels like your favorite party snack.

22. Hot Honey Drizzle

Hot Honey Drizzle
© The Practical Kitchen

Sometimes the best topping goes on last. Hot honey, which is honey infused with chili peppers, has become a modern pizza superstar.

New York pizzeria Paulie Gee’s helped make it popular with a pie called the Hellboy. The sweet heat clings to crispy pepperoni and salty cheese perfectly.

Making your own is simple. Warm honey with red pepper flakes for a few minutes, then drizzle away.

23. Meatballs

Meatballs
© Simply Stacie

Spaghetti night and pizza night finally meet. Sliced meatballs turn any pie into a hearty, belly-filling feast.

Leftover homemade meatballs work wonderfully, though frozen ones save time. Cut them into thin rounds so they heat through evenly.

A sprinkle of parmesan and fresh basil makes it taste like a trip to an old-school Italian diner. This is the slice to grab when you are seriously hungry.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.